There is (and always has been) a lot of controversy regarding the glycemic index (GI), which is a measure that is used to see how quickly a certain food can raise your blood sugar. Since a persistently high blood sugar can really wreak havoc on your health, it seems like the GI would be a useful tool for many people.
But many practitioners and patients don't like to use it in the context of diets and weight loss programs because (a) it doesn't always make intuitive sense and (b) patients make the wrong assumptions about it and thus, use it improperly.
If you base your diet on glycemic index alone, it is true that you will not have much success in either losing weight or controlling your blood sugar. There are plenty of low-glycemic index foods like ice cream, which would not count as health foods in ANY diet. Likewise, trying to adjust glycemic index by adding fat and fiber to your meals (which generally reduced the GI or most foods) can lead you to thinking that a chocolate milkshake with extra flax seed is a health food. It really isn't.
But if you understand how the glycemic index works in context with the basic of good eating, I still think GI can be a valuable adjunct in helping you make informed choices regarding what foods to eat and not to eat.
But here's the thing: you have to be able to use your brain.
This means you have to understand the GI as a general guideline, to help you manage your food choices, so you can identify foods that you have trouble with (raise your blood sugar, leave you hungry 2 hours later, and make you gain weight) so you can avoid them.
It sometimes has exceptions and works counter-intuitively (eg ice cream). So, instead of being a GPS it acts more like a compass, in a sense. It will show the general direction of where you might want to go, but if there is a river or a deep gorge, you might have to alter your path a bit. Ultimately, the GI won't tell you exactly where you are, you will need other information to help you do that so that you will be able to incorporate foods that you do like safely into your diet.
And if you really want to understand the GI--I mean REALLY understand it--then get a glucometer and check it yourself. That's right. If you are serious about knowing about your GI, then know your GI!